Software M&A - Review and Analysis of 2003
By Ken Bender, Managing Director, and Allen Cinzori, Vice President - Software Equity Group, LLC
Copyright © 2003,
Software Equity Group, L.L.C.
|
|
Economy
The U.S. economy gained considerable
momentum in 2003. Most notable was a significant improvement in Gross Domestic
Product (GDP), a leading economic indicator, which reached its highest level
since 1984. While third quarter GDP grew at the sizzling rate of 8.2%, the rate
decelerated to a more sustainable 4.0% in Q4. For the year, GDP grew 3.1%, as
compared to 2.2% in 2002 and 0.5% in 2001 (Figure 1).

Key contributors to the upturn in GDP
were a
significant increase in business
investments and
strong consumer spending, both of which
surged in the third quarter. Business investments in equipment and software
jumped 17.6% in Q3 and 10.0% in Q4. A weaker dollar and an improving global
economy also drove the manufacturing sector, as demand for U.S. exports grew
19.1%, a seven year high, offsetting a 11.3% rise in imports. Consumers, who
single-handedly kept the economy afloat in 2001 and 2002, continued to
capitalize on decade low interest rates.
The Conference Board's Composite Index
of Leading Economic Indicators, an important short-term forecasting tool,
improved steadily the last three quarters of 2003, reaching the highest level
in its history by year-end. Positive contributors included building permits,
consumer optimism, new manufacturing orders for both non-defense and consumer
goods, and stock market performance.
While the economic indicators were
largely positive, there remained reason for caution. The number of unemployed
was 8.4 million in December, 5.7% of the job force. While the number of jobless
was down from the recent high in June 2003, the unemployment rate remained
stubbornly high and reflected a drop-off in job seekers. The civilian labor
force fell by 309,000 in December to 146.9 million; the labor force
participation rate decreased over the month to 66.0%.
Entering the new year, consensus
estimates put 2004 GDP at a sustained economic expansion rate of 4.5%, with
business investments leading consumer spending. Consumer spending is expected
to flatten or decline slightly as home sales weaken, interest rates rise and
consumers begin to feel the impact of increased household debt and reduced
savings.
Public
Markets
U.S. markets ended a torrid year on yet
another upswing in Q4, with the Dow, Nasdaq and S&P 500 climbing 13%, 12%
and 12%. For the year, these same indices were up 25%, 49% and 26% (Figure 2).
As a group, public software companies outpaced the broader market. For the
year, the average market value of the SEG-Seventy,
our index of public software companies, climbed 57%. The median market cap of the SEG-Seventy grew 78%. Other Q4 market indices for the SEG- Seventy compared to the prior quarter:
·
Median revenue multiple for the group
grew 11% to 2.8 times trailing-twelve-month (TTM) revenue.
·
Median enterprise value (adding debt
and deducting cash and cash equivalents) to revenue multiple increased 26% to
2.1x TTM.
·
Median P/E ratio climbed 11% to 36.9x.
·
Median multiple of EBITDA was 25.2x,
up 20%.
·
Average operating profit margin before
depreciation, interest and taxes declined to 15.2% from 16.7% in Q3.
·
Average revenue multiple for the SEG-Seventy was 3.6x (up from 3.1x in the
prior period), and the corresponding confidence interval at 80% was 3.3x to
3.9x.

As expected, the markets continued to
disproportionately reward the industry’s largest players – those public
software companies with the greatest
revenue. Similar to last quarter, the 20 software companies in the SEG-Seventy with revenue between $200
million and $1 billion had a 2.8x median revenue multiple in Q4, as compared to
2.6x for companies with revenues below $200 million. Similarly, companies with
revenue in excess of $1 billion recorded the highest median revenue multiple for
the quarter, 5.0x. On an earnings basis, companies with revenue greater than
$200 million had a7 median P/E of more than 40x, compared with 28x for those
with revenue less than $200 million.
Public software company performance,
however, did not keep track with escalating market caps and higher PEs. Median
revenue of the SEG-Seventy
actually declined 2.6% in 2003 from 2002 (Figure 3). Earnings of the group
improved however, with the median growing 6.8% (Figure 4). Given the belt
tightening that has occurred over the past three years, top line growth will
likely be required to generate earnings sufficient to justify current market
valuations.
Prospects for software company revenue growth appear better in 2004
than anytime in the past three years, but opinions vary. Both Gartner Group and
IDC project a 5.0% increase in IT spending, but Goldman Sachs’ December survey
of IT executives portends only a 1.5% increase in IT budgets (down from a 2.3%
estimate in August, and a 3.5% estimate in June). Gartner also projects that IT
spending will be greatest in the government and health care sectors during the
next five years, each averaging in excess of 12% compounded annual growth. The
financial services, education, manufacturing and communications sectors are each
projected to increase IT spending by more than 6.5% over the same five year
period.
The market valuations of public software
companies continued to vary widely according to principal product focus,
although virtually all categories saw quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year
increases (Figure 5). SEG-Seventy
median revenue multiples by principal product category for Q4 were:

·
Business Intelligence (BI): 4.2x (up
from 3.4x in Q3)
·
CAD/CAE: 2.8x (up from 2.2x)
·
Customer Relationship Management
(CRM): 2.0x (up from 1.5x)
·
Developer Tools (DT): 2.5x (down from
3.2x)
·
Enterprise Application Integration
(EAI): 2.6x (up from 2.5x)
·
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP):
3.4x (up from 2.4x)
·
Information / Data Management (IM):
3.0x (up from 2.5x)
·
Security: 4.5x (up from 3.6x)
·
Supply Chain Management (SCM): 2.6x
(up from 1.8x)
As in Q3, publicly traded security
software developers boasted the highest market values, with median Q4 revenue
multiples increasing an additional 24% over the prior quarter. Business intelligence
software companies posted a 25% increase in the quarter, even though Cognos
guided down next quarter expectations after beating analyst expectations.
Public software companies focused primarily on enterprise resource planning
(ERP) and customer relationship management (CRM) posted dramatic gains for the
year of 227% and 87%, respectively. The developer tools segment, which has held
much of its value in the past two years was hardest hit in the quarter,
declining in market value 21.6% to 2.5x.

Initial Public Offerings
The market for initial public offerings
(IPOs) declined
in 2003 relative to 2002. Only 73 deals
priced, raising
an aggregate $15 billion, making 2003
one of the slowest years on record (Figure 6). However 89% of these IPOs, and 92%
of all proceeds, came in the third and fourth quarters. 19 companies made it to
market in Q3 and 42 were listed in Q4, suggesting there may finally be light at
the end of the IPO tunnel in 2004 (Figure 7).
Venture-backed IPOs accounted for 29 of
the offerings (40% of total activity) and raised an aggregate $2.3 billion (15%
of overall funds raised). Perhaps signaling a trend, foreign issuers garnered
more than 40% of 2003 IPO proceeds. The financial services sector led the IPO
market with the largest number of offerings at sixteen.
Eight software companies went public in
2003, with seven coming to market in the second half of the year (Table 1). By
year-end, these software companies were up a group average of 21% from their
initial offering price. This contrasts sharply with 2002’s five software IPOs
which declined an average 26% in price from date of offering to year-end.
iPayment, a provider of credit/debit
card-based payment processing services to small merchants, climbed 114% from
its offering price. Not all 2003 IPOs fared as well. By year-end, DVD software
developer Intervideo had declined 21% and online travel agency Orbitz was down
10%. Perhaps most curiously, Kintera, an ASP targeted at non-profit
organizations, was up 58% from its offering price. Kintera’s IPO supported more
than a $225 million market cap for a company with less than $6 million in
revenue, in an underwriting that harkened back to the “good old days” of 1999.
Four of the eight “software” companies
categorized as 2003 IPOs primarily sell services rather than traditional
“shrink-wrapped” or packaged software. These “software as a service” providers,
iPayment, DigitalNet, Orbitz and Kintera, performed well as a group. Orbitz was
the only company posting negative returns at year-end. Callidus, a provider of
incentive management software, and Open Solutions, a provider of software and
services for financial institutions, were the only traditional enterprise
software companies to come to market in the period. Given the relatively strong
level of activity in Q3 and Q4, and the continued strength of the overall
equity markets, 2004 looks promising for software IPOs.

Private Equity
Overall, U.S. venture capital
investments continued to decline in 2003, but apparently found bottom. With
$18.2 billion invested in 2,715 companies, the number of companies funded in
2003 dropped by 12% (from 3,035) and dollars invested fell 18% (from $21.4
billion) in 2002. The average investment also fell by 5%, to $6.7 million. On a
positive note, Q4 showed some reason for optimism, with $4.9 billion invested
in 679 entities. (Figure 8).

Software, once again, continued to lead
all other
industry sectors in attracting VC
investment, with
718 companies funded in 2003 (20% of the
total).
Relative to 2002, the number of software
industry VC
investments declined 17%. In dollar
terms, $3.6 billion was invested in software businesses in 2003, compared to
$4.5 billion in 2002 and $8.8 billion in 2001. However Q4 showed a 13%
improvement over Q3, with 145 software companies financed. Notable IT fundings
included Grande Communications ($45 million), Vonage ($35 million), Alereon
($31.5 million) and Egenera ($30 million).
By comparison, two adjacent industry
sectors,
Biotechnology and Medical Device
companies attracted a combined $4.89 billion, or 27% of all venture capital.
69% of that amount went to biotech, with the balance invested primarily into medical
devices. VC investments in telecommunications, networking, and semiconductors
continued to decline in 2003, dropping to 11%, 9% and 6% of total investments.
In terms of the life cycle stage on companies
funded, 2003 mirrored 2002 for much of
the year,
but hinted at change by year-end. VCs
continued to
flock to relative safety, investing $4.7
billion in later
stage companies (26% of total) in 2003,
the highest percentage for that category in the past 20 years according to
MoneyTree (Figure 9). The average investment for later stage companies was $9.4
million. However, VC funding of less mature, expansion stage entities declined
22% in value from 2002, with $9.9 billion invested in 1,339 companies. Early
stage company financing followed suit, declining 20% from 2002, to $3.3
billion. Funding for the youngest, seed
stage entities leveled off at $354 million for the year, after plummeting 800%
since 2000 (Figure 10). Viewed on a quarter-by-quarter basis, however, seed
stage financing was erratic throughout the year, with Q4 declining 53% from
Q3’s surprising $126 million windfall.
Across all industries, 624 companies received first-time funding
totaling $3.4 billion, a decline of 27% from 2002. However Q4 first-time
financings were 35% greater in amount than in Q3. Software was the leading
sector for first-time financings, with 156 companies receiving $691 million.
The closest competing segment was biotech, with 71 companies raising $462
million.
On a bright note, VCs raised $5.2
billion from limited partners in Q4, almost half the $10.8 billion raised for
all of 2003. According to industry tracker VentureOne, nearly half the VCs
surveyed said they expected to raise more money from limited partners in 2004.
Mergers
& Acquisitions: The Trends
What drove this deal? It’s a question we
ask every day as we review the most recent software industry transactions. To
understand trends in software M&A, it’s essential to understand buyer
motives, which shift over time to reflect fluctuations in the economy, changes in IT spending and new technologies
which presage widespread market adoption. As those motives shift, so do the
types of companies buyers target, and the prices they’ll pay. What were the
deal drivers in 2003, and how did they impact valuations and purchase prices?
How did buyer thinking evolve in 2003, and what does it portend for 2004?
A deal-by-deal analysis of transaction
analyzed in 1H03 reveals fully 65% were driven by buyers, primarily public
software companies, seeking small and mid-cap companies with strong financials,
a suite of products, technology/market leadership and a significant installed
base. Most were unwilling to stray far from home. Buyers sought an almost
perfect strategic fit, acquiring companies which targeted the same market with
highly complementary products and compatible technology. Examples abound,
including JDA’s purchase of Vista Software for 1.0 times trailing-twelve-month
(TTM) revenue, Serena Software’s acquisition of TeamShare for 1.4x, and
FileNet’s acquisition of Shana for 1.1x.
Simply put, buyers in Q1 and Q2 sought
incremental revenue at bargain basement prices. Median revenue valuations for
software deals in Q1 and Q2 were 1.1x and 1.2x, respectively. There were few
buyers, and most paid cash rather than use deflated stock as deal currency.
Acquired companies had to have sufficient recurring revenue to pay for themselves
in two or three years. Slightly higher prices were paid for companies which
could generate incremental revenue almost immediately by cross-selling the
buyer’s products into the seller’s installed base, and vice-versa.
In Q3, however, we began to discern a
shift in buyer thinking. While the majority of transactions reflected the safe
bet / incremental revenue rationale of Q1 and Q2, buyers proved more
adventurous and less risk adverse in some 25% of the transactions. Public
software companies were buoyed by sharply rebounding tech sector stock prices.
The improving economy suggested increased corporate IT spending might follow
shortly. For the first time in two and a half years, public software companies
felt pressed to respond to competition and changing market requirements by
acquiring proven solutions which would enhance the buyers’ offerings. We call
these “strategic technology” buyers. Examples: Proprietary storage software
vendor EMC acknowledges it must offer open platform storage technology and
acquires Legato for $1.24 billion, a 4.4x TTM multiple; web content management
provider Interwoven, losing deals to Documentum’s end-to-end knowledge
management suite, pays $136 million, a 3.2x TTM multiple, to pick up iManage, a
leader in content collaboration and document management to fill in the gaps.
Q3 also saw a sharp increase in vertical
software acquisitions with more than 20 deals, particularly in the health care,
financial services and legal markets. There were some 10 security software
company sales in Q3, and almost as many wireless software company M&A
transactions. There was a sharp decline, however, in financial buyouts, which
is not surprising, given the median valuation multiple increased again, this
time to 1.6x.
Q4 saw the number of buyers seeking
bargains close to home decrease further, to about 40% of total transactions.
The number of “strategic technology” buys, however, ramped sharply in Q4 to 48%
of total transactions. Increasingly, buyers sought to add incremental
technologies to materially enhance their core products, improve the end-user
experience, and compete more effectively. Buyers beefed up help desk offerings
with e-communications management (Primus / Amacis Group), web-publishing
products with e-learning (Macromedia / eHelp), and online content with mobile
media (InfoSpace / Moviso).
Some of Q4 remained standard fare. We
counted four rollups, which we define as combining companies with functional
components to comprise a full-fledged, standard category offering (e.g., HR +
Accounting + Manufacturing +Supply chain + Logistics = ERP). We also saw four
software companies taken out by direct competitors, and four buyouts by private
equity firms or their proxies. 10 pure vertical software companies sold in Q4,
down from 19 in Q3.

But Q4 also revealed a marked change in acquisition strategy
for a surprising number of buyers. About one out of five buyers decided to
venture well beyond their traditional space. In many cases, buyers acquired an
entirely new software category, as they sought to diversify their revenue base,
and in some cases reinvent themselves. A leading enterprise systems management
provider added help desk software for SMEs (BMC / Magic Solutions). The
behemoth of storage management added the leading content management developer
(EMC / Documentum), and the leading Linux provider added storage management to
its product line (Red Hat / Sistina). A market leader in security software
expanded into enterprise infrastructure management (Symantec / ON Technology),
and a healthcare ecommerce provider picked up a developer of object-oriented
infrastructure software (Quovadx / Rogue Wave). The median M&A valuation
multiple increased once again in Q4 to 2.1 times TTM revenue, driven in large
part by higher multiples paid by these new software category buyers, as well as
strategic technology buyers.
Mergers
and Acquisitions: The Numbers
Overall, U.S. merger and acquisition
activity showed noticeable improvement in 2003, halting a steady two year
decline (Figure 11). For the year, domestic M&A activity for all industry
sectors increased 10% to 8,198 transactions, and dollar value, at $529 billion,
was up 20%.

Software mergers
and acquisitions continued to lead all other industry sectors in number of
transactions, with 1,325 deals, almost identical to 2002’s tally (Figure 12).
After a very slow start in Q1, software M&A activity increased 10% in Q2
and 27% in Q3, but was flat in Q4. In terms of M&A dollar volume, software
placed third behind banking & finance and insurance, but the $44 billion
spent on software company acquisitions was 52% greater than 2002 (Figure 13).
The sharp increase in aggregate purchase price can be chalked up to both
improved valuations and a greater number of “mega” deals, including Peoplesoft
/ J.D. Edwards, EMC / Documentum, EMC / Legato and Business Objects / Crystal
Decisions. In contrast, IBM / Rational and Microsoft / Navision were 2002’s
only billion dollar deals. Software company exit valuations improved
steadily
throughout 2003 (Figure 14). As noted
above, the median software company M&A
valuation (based on the equity purchase price) reached 2.1 times
trailing-twelve-month (TTM) revenue, almost two times the M&A median
valuation in Q1. For the year, the median software company M&A valuation,
measured as a multiple of TTM revenue, was 1.6x.

As in prior
years, software M&A valuations varied widely by product category (Figure
15). Categories which enterprise customers perceived as high investment /
questionable return, such as ERP, CRM and supply chain software, lagged well
behind lower investment / measurable return categories, such as storage
management, systems management and developer tools. Valuations were
also higher in
categories where leaders played catch-up with key competitors or redefined
themselves by moving aggressively into a new category. Median revenue multiples
by software product category were as follows:
·
Accounting/Finance, 2.6x
·
Business Intelligence, 1.5x
• Content/Document
management, 1.4x
• Customer
relationship management, 1.2x
• Data management, 1.3x
• Developer
tools, 2.9x
• Enterprise
resource planning, 1.0x
• Security,
2.5x
• Storage
management, 5.0x
·
Supply chain management, 0.7x
·
Systems/Infrastructure management,
4.2x
Since early 2001,
cash has been king in software M&A, and 2003 proved no exception. 54% of
transactions were all cash, 19% all stock and 27% a combination of cash and
stock (Figure 16). The use of stock as currency, however, ramped sharply as the
year progressed, reflecting rapidly escalating tech sector stock prices. In
1H03, 67% of transactions were all cash, while only 19% were all stock and 14%
a combination of the two. As the market rebounded, both buyers and sellers saw
more value in stock as currency. In 2H03, 45% of software M&A transactions were
all cash, 19% all stock and 35% a combination of the two (Figure 17).
In a period
characterized by higher valuations and increased use of stock as currency, we’d
expect to see a predominance of public buyers and private sellers. And so it
was. Of 575 major software transactions we analyzed, 76% had public buyers and
86% private sellers.

Mergers
and Acquisitions: Most Active
Buyers
2003 saw a significant increase over
2002 in multi-transaction buyers. It was not unusal to see the same buyer
roll-up a competitor, beef up its core offering with a strategic technology
buy, and acquire a leading player in an adjacent market or product category.
Some of the year’s most active buyers:
|
Agile
Software
·
Eigner
·
MS2
·
OneREV
·
ProductFactory
·
Tradec
Amdocs Limited
·
Certain
·
Exchange Applications
·
XACCT Technologies
Cadence Design Systems
·
Get2Chip
·
K2
Technologies
·
Verplex Systems
Chinadotcom
·
Industri-Matematik
International
·
Pivotal
·
Ross
Systems
Eastman
Kodak
·
Algotec
Systems
·
MiraMedica
·
PracticeWorks
·
Scitex
Corp. (select assets)
EMC Corporation
·
Astrum
Software Corporation
·
Documentum
·
Legato
Systems
·
Vmware
Epicor
Software Corporation
·
ROI
Systems
·
Scala
Business Solutions
·
CompuNet
(select assets)
·
TDC
Solutions
Hewlett-Packard
Company
·
Baltimore
Technologies (select assets)
·
Extreme
Logic
·
Persist
Technologies
·
PipeBeach
AB
·
Talking
Blocks
Hummingbird
·
Key
Automation Nederland B.V.
·
Kramer
Lee & Associates
·
LegalKEY
Technologies
·
Valid
Information Systems
International
Business Machines
·
Aptrix
·
Green
Pasture Software Key Automation
·
Productivity
Solutions
·
Sector7
(select assets)
·
Think
Dynamics
International
Microcomputer Software
·
CADalog.com
·
CADKEY
·
Upperspace
Corp. (select assets)
Lawson
Software
·
Apexion
Technologies
·
Closedloop
Solutions
·
Numbercraft
Mercury
Interactive Corp.
·
Allerez
Corp. (select assets)
·
Kintana
·
Performant
|
Microsoft
Corporation
·
GeCAD
Software
·
PlaceWare
·
Connectix
Corp. (assets)
Network
Associates
·
Deersoft
·
Entercept
Security Technologies
·
IntruVert
Networks
Open
Text
·
Corechange
·
Eloquent
·
Gauss
Interprise
·
IXOS
Software AG
·
SER
eGovernment
Pumatech
·
Loudfire
·
Spontaneous
Technology
·
Starfish
Software
·
Synchrologic
Reynolds
and Reynolds
·
Incadea
AG
·
MSN
Auto Dealerpoint
·
Third
Coast Media
Science
Applications International
·
Atlantic
Coast Telesys
·
Computer
Systems Technology
·
Opta
·
Predictive
Systems Unit
·
SCIENTECH
·
VGS
Siebel
Systems
·
BoldFish
·
Motiva
(select assets)
·
UpShot
SSA
Global Technologies
·
Elevon
·
EXE
Technologies
·
Ironside
Technologies
Sun
Microsystems
·
CenterRun
·
Pixo
·
Waveset
Technologies
SunGard
Data Systems
·
FAME
Information Services
·
HTE
·
Sherwood
International PLC
·
Systems
& Computer Technology
Symantec
·
Nexland
·
ON
Technology
·
PowerQuest
·
Safeweb
Synopsys
·
InnoLogic
Systems
·
Numerical
Technologies
·
Qualis
(select assets)
The
Sage Group
·
ATW
Computer Services
·
Concept
Group
·
Groupo
SP
·
Softline
·
Timberline
Software
|
Mergers and Acquisitions: Most Active Software
Industry Categories
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Best Software
|
ACCPAC International
|
$110,000,000
|
$88,700,000
|
1.2x
|
Provides end-to-end business management applications
|
|
Digital Insight Corp.
|
Magnet Comm.
|
$61,615,000
|
$17,000,000
|
3.6x
|
Web-based business banking solutions for financial institutions
|
|
Imaging Technologies
|
Greenland Corp.
|
$2,250,000
|
$334,000
|
6.7x
|
Provides wide range of automated financial services
|
|
Intuit
|
Income Dynamics
|
$10,000,000
|
$3,500,000 (estimate)
|
2.9x
|
Collector and provider of fair market values of donations
|
|
The Sage Group
|
Concept Group
|
$10,890,000
|
$16,250,000
|
0.7x
|
Provides treasury, cash management and financial
consolidation solutions
|
|
The Sage Group
|
Groupo SP
|
$93,500,000
|
$38,300,000
|
2.4x
|
Entry-level accounting software to the Spanish market
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Acxiom Corp.
|
Claritas Europe
|
$40,000,000
|
$100,000,000
|
0.4x
|
Provide the largest source of consumer lifestyle and
behavioral information for effective marketing across Europe
|
|
Business Objects
|
Crystal Decisions
|
$820,000,000
|
$270,000,000
|
3.0x
|
Software includes reporting, analysis, and information
delivery, as well as related services
|
|
CheckFree Holdings Corp.
|
HelioGraph
|
$18,300,000
|
$8,000,000
|
2.3x
|
Supplies Transaction Process Management (TPM) tools for
the securities industry
|
|
Geac Computer Corp.
|
Comshare, Inc.
|
$52,000,000
|
$58,300,000
|
0.9x
|
Develop, market and support management planning and
control application software
|
|
Hyperion Solutions Corp.
|
Brio Software Inc.
|
$142,000,000
|
$101,800,000
|
1.4x
|
Help companies extract, integrate, analyze and report
information
|
|
MapInfo Corp.
|
Thompson Associates
|
$13,000,000
|
$13,000,000
|
1.0x
|
Provide retail market analytics
|
|
Mercury Interactive
Corp.
|
Kintana, Inc.
|
$225,000,000
|
$44,500,000
|
5.1x
|
Software digitizes and integrates IT business processes
from demand to production, enabling real-time decision-making and execution
for both strategic projects and 'keep-the-lights-on' activities
|
|
NetRatings
|
RedSheriff
|
$12,000,000
|
$7,500,000
|
1.6x
|
Provides tools and services that help companies optimize
their Web sites
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Bottomline
Technologies
|
Create!form
International
|
$7,375,000
|
$4,500,000 (estimate)
|
1.6x
|
Provide
solutions to financial transactions including invoicing, payments, and
reporting
|
|
Eastman
Kodak Co.
|
Algotec
Systems
|
$42,500,000
|
$1,250,000 (estimate)
|
34.0x
|
Provides
Healthcare facilities with Web enabled, advanced solutions for Medical
Imaging
|
|
Electronics
for Imaging
|
T/R
Systems
|
$21,000,000
|
$14,739,000
|
1.4x
|
Provides
the printing and publishing industry with an integrated software suite that
transforms digital copiers and printers into print-on-demand systems
|
|
EMC Corp.
|
Documentum
|
$1,700,000,000
|
$274,724,000
|
6.2x
|
Provides
ECM solutions that enable organizations to unite teams, content and
associated business processes
|
|
FileNET
Corp.
|
Shana
Corporation
|
$8,500,000
|
$7,500,000 (estimate)
|
1.1x
|
Provider
of electronic forms software
|
|
Interwoven
|
iManage
|
$171,000,000
|
$41,326,000
|
4.1x
|
Content
management software that enables businesses to manage and collaborate on
critical business content
|
|
iXOS
Software AG
|
Obtree
Technologies
|
$5,000,000
|
$11,280,000
|
0.4x
|
Supplier
of content management solutions
|
|
Open Text
Corp.
|
IXOS
Software
|
$226,000,000
|
$145,000,000
|
1.6x
|
Software
solutions for the management of business documents
|
|
Primus
Knowledge Solutions
|
Amacis
Group
|
$6,966,132
|
$6,250,000 (estimate)
|
1.1x
|
Electronic
communications management solutions to global enterprises
|
|
Savvis
Comm. Corp.
|
Wam!Net’s
commercial business unit
|
$3,000,000
|
$30,000,000
|
0.1x
|
Provider
of digital content management and distribution services
|
|
SERENA
Software
|
TeamShare
|
$18,000,000
|
$12,500,000 (estimate)
|
1.4x
|
Web-based
enterprise collaborative software
|
|
SSA
Global Technologies
|
Elevon
|
$20,280,000
|
$41,900,000
|
0.5x
|
Collaborative
commerce and knowledge management
|
|
Vignette
Corporation
|
Intraspect
Software
|
$20,000,000
|
$17,500,000 (estimate)
|
1.1x
|
Provider
of enterprise solutions that power complex business processes, manage content
lifecycles and enhance internal and external collaboration
|
|
VitalWorks
|
AMICAS
|
$30,000,000
|
$6,250,000 (estimate)
|
4.8x
|
Provides
Web-based medical and diagnostic image management software for health care
providers
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
24/7
Media
|
Real
Media Korea Co.
|
$21,000,000
|
$11,000,000
|
1.9x
|
Provides
interactive marketing in the Republic of South Korea
|
|
Amdocs
Ltd.
|
Exchange
Applications
|
$5,000,000
|
$24,400,000
|
0.2x
|
Offer
marketing campaign management capabilities
|
|
Chinadotcom
Corp.
|
Pivotal
Corp.
|
$56,239,200
|
$57,072,000
|
1.0x
|
Software
that enables medium-sized enterprises worldwide to acquire, serve and manage
their customers
|
|
Dendrite
International
|
SYNAVANT
|
$49,000,000
|
$156,200,000
|
0.3x
|
Solutions
provider servicing the biopharmaceutical and healthcare industries
|
|
Interwoven
|
MediaBin
|
$5,000,000
|
$1,750,000 (estimate)
|
2.9x
|
Enables
enterprises to promote their products in multi-channel marketing programs
|
|
Island
Pacific
|
Page
Digital
|
$7,000,000
|
$6,000,000 (estimate)
|
1.2x
|
Provider
of multi-channel software applications designed to enable effective
operational diversity
|
|
Jaguar
Technology Holdings
|
Firepond
|
$10,112,000
|
$13,800,000
|
0.7x
|
Provides
enterprise software that is used to manage customer interactions
|
|
Open Text
Corp.
|
Eloquent
|
$6,720,000
|
$2,490,000
|
2.7x
|
Allows companies
to create, distribute, and track rich media presentations
|
|
Reynolds
and Reynolds Co.
|
Third
Coast Media
|
$8,000,000
|
$5,000,000
|
1.6x
|
Software
development company with a focus on providing web-based software solutions
primarily for the automotive industry
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Ascential
Software
|
Mercator
Software
|
$106,000,000
|
$102,600,000
|
1.0x
|
Business
integration software solutions to global enterprises
|
|
DataMirror
Corp.
|
PointBase
|
$3,500,000
|
$2,750,000 (estimate)
|
1.3x
|
Provider
java based relational database and synchronization solutions
|
|
Group 1
Software
|
Sagent
Technology
|
$17,000,000
|
$37,900,000
|
0.5x
|
Data flow
server enables business users to easily extend the structure of a data
warehouse
|
|
Infowave
Software
|
Sproqit
Technologies
|
$987,200
|
$2,000,000 (estimate)
|
0.5x
|
Offers a
mobile application platform that enables users to obtain data via hand held
personal digital assistant ("PDA")
|
|
Kofax
Image Products
|
Mohomine
|
$9,000,000
|
$1,500,000 (estimate)
|
6.0x
|
Automated
text classification and extraction
|
|
NVIDIA
Corp.
|
MediaQ
|
$70,000,000
|
$12,500,000 (estimate)
|
5.6x
|
Provides
software to manufacturers of mobile devices
|
|
Progress
Software
|
DataDirect
Tech. Ltd.
|
$88,000,000
|
$35,500,000 (estimate)
|
2.5x
|
Provider
of components for connecting software to relational and XML data
|
|
Pumatech
|
Synchrologic
|
$60,000,000
|
$11,800,000
|
5.1x
|
Mobilizes
enterprise email and applications, automates the delivery of documents and
Web sites, and provides mobile systems management tools
|
|
Stellent,
Inc.
|
Ancept
|
$2,826,000
|
$4,500,000 (estimate)
|
0.6x
|
Provides
digital asset management applications
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Macromedia
|
eHelp Corp.
|
$65,000,000
|
$22,300,000
(estimate)
|
2.9x
|
Assists developers in creating
and publishing help modules
|
|
Novell
|
SUSE Linux
|
$210,000,000
|
$35,400,000
|
5.9x
|
Provider of Linux software and
services
|
|
Pervasive Software
|
Data Junction Corp.
|
$51,700,000
|
$14,000,000
|
3.7x
|
Data transformation tools
|
|
Quovadx
|
Rogue Wave Software
|
$71,000,000
|
$32,900,000
|
2.2x
|
Markets and supports
object-oriented and infrastructure software technology.
|
|
SCO Group
|
Vultus
|
$2,700,000
|
$1,250,000
(estimate)
|
2.2x
|
Web service technology
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Battery
Ventures
|
Made 2
Manage
Systems
|
$30,000,000
|
$30,100,000
|
1.0x
|
Enterprise business systems
designed for small and midsize manufacturers and distributors
|
|
Cerberus
Capital Management
|
Baan
|
$135,000,000
|
$265,000,000
|
0.5x
|
Manufacturing
enterprise solutions
|
|
Chinadotcom
Corp.
|
Ross
Systems
|
$68,900,000
|
$48,100,000
|
1.4x
|
Enterprise solutions software
designed for process manufacturing companies
|
|
Epicor
Software
|
ROI
Systems Inc.
|
$21,433,000
|
$23,659,389
|
0.9x
|
Extended enterprise resource
planning solutions
|
|
Epicor
Software
|
Scala
Business Solutions
|
$87,000,000
|
$71,240,000
|
1.2x
|
Offers a collaborative ERP
system to make business simple
|
|
Indus
International
|
SCT's
GEUS business unit
|
$39,000,000
|
$74,200,000
|
0.5x
|
Provides advanced software and
services solutions for utilities and energy service companies
|
|
PeopleSoft
|
J.D.
Edwards
|
$1,750,000,000
|
$886,000,000
|
2.0x
|
Develops and markets
collaborative enterprise software and provides consulting, education and
support services
|
|
Primavera
Systems
|
Evolve
Software
|
$13,000,000
|
$18,300,000
|
0.7x
|
Enterprise software that optimizes
the way organizations deliver services to their customers and employees
|
|
Reynolds
and Reynolds Co.
|
Incadea
AG
|
$7,000,000
|
$6,000,000
|
1.2x
|
Developer of a software
platform for automotive built on Microsoft Navision
|
|
Speedware
|
Enterprise
Computer Systems
|
$12,000,000
|
$20,200,000
(estimate)
|
0.6x
|
Provides a wide range of
technology to their building materials distribution customers
|
|
Tecnomatix
Technologies
|
USDATA
Corp.
|
$10,300,000
|
$10,900,000
|
0.9x
|
Global provider of software and
services
|
|
The Sage
Group
|
Timberline
Software Corp.
|
$102,900,000
|
$63,100,000
|
1.6x
|
Develops, markets and supports
financial and operations software for the construction and real estate
industries
|
*Equity Value
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
BeTRUSTed
|
Baltimore
Tech. Managed Svcs Unit
|
$1,750,000
|
$1,500,000
|
1.2x
|
Issues
digital certificates from a secure hosting facility
|
|
Blue Coat
Systems
|
Ositis
Software
|
$7,529,020
|
$6,250,000 (estimate)
|
1.2x
|
Develops,
licenses, and markets software and hardware solutions that provide customers
with a system to safeguard and connect networked PCs
|
|
Check
Point Software Technologies Ltd.
|
Zone Labs
|
$205,000,000
|
$20,000,000
(estimate)
|
10.3x
|
Endpoint
security solutions
|
|
Cisco
Systems
|
Okena
|
$154,000,000
|
$6,000,000
(estimate)
|
25.7x
|
Network
security software
|
|
CyberGuard
Corp.
|
SnapGear
|
$16,000,000
|
$8,750,000 (estimate)
|
1.8x
|
Provides
design, engineering and fulfillment services for network appliances that
ensure secure Internet communications for business
|
|
Netegrity
|
Business
Layers
|
$42,500,000
|
$8,750,000 (estimate)
|
4.9x
|
Global
provider of provisioning software for identity management solutions
|
|
NetScreen
Technologies
|
Neoteris
|
$265,000,000
|
$30,000,000
|
8.8x
|
SSL VPN
and application security gateway products
|
|
SafeNet
|
Rainbow
Technologies
|
$457,000,000
|
$126,052,000
|
3.6x
|
Global
provider of information technology security solutions
|
|
Science
Applications International
|
Predictive
Systems Unit
|
$1,927,400
|
$1,380,000
|
1.4x
|
Perform
analyses and notification of both physical and cyber threats,
vulnerabilities, and warnings
|
|
Secure
Computing Corp.
|
N2H2
|
$19,900,000
|
$11,100,000
|
1.8x
|
Content
filtering and monitoring solutions
|
|
Symantec
Corp.
|
Safeweb
|
$26,000,000
|
$2,500,000 (estimate)
|
10.4x
|
Designs
secure remote access solutions
|
|
Symantec
Corporation
|
Nexland
|
$19,600,000
|
$7,740,000
|
2.5x
|
Internet
security company
|
|
Tumbleweed
Communications Corp.
|
Valicert
|
$14,300,000
|
$12,200,000
|
1.2x
|
Provider
of secure communications and authentication software
|
*Equity Value
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Applied
Micro Circuits Corp.
|
JNI Corp.
|
$190,000,000
|
$38,362,000
|
5.0x
|
Designer
and supplier of Fibre Channel enterprise storage connectivity products that
connect servers and data storage devices
|
|
EMC Corp.
|
Legato
Systems
|
$1,300,000,000
|
$280,300,000
|
4.6x
|
Markets
and supports storage software products and services worldwide
|
|
Network
Appliance
|
Spinnaker
Networks
|
$300,000,000
|
$12,500,000 (estimate)
|
24.0x
|
Provides
next-generation networked storage solutions
|
|
Red Hat
|
Sistina
Software
|
$31,000,000
|
$2,250,000 (estimate)
|
13.8x
|
Provider
of storage infrastructure software
|
|
Symantec
Corp.
|
PowerQuest
Corp.
|
$150,000,000
|
$50,000,000
|
3.0x
|
Allows
enterprise customers to add new storage, reconfigure existing storage,
monitor and manage storage devices
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
Chinadotcom
Corp.
|
Industri-Matematik
International Corp
|
$25,000,000
|
$45,000,000 (estimate)
|
0.6x
|
Supply
chain solutions for the midmarket
|
|
Electronics
for Imaging
|
Printcafe
Software
|
$27,560,000
|
$44,200,000
|
0.6x
|
Software
solutions designed specifically for the printing industry
|
|
JDA
Software Group
|
Vista
Software Solutions' IP Assets
|
$4,300,000
|
$4,300,000
|
1.0x
|
Web-based
trade funds management solution
|
|
SSA
Global Technologies
|
EXE
Technologies
|
$47,357,000
|
$70,800,000
|
0.7x
|
Provides
software that helps drive customers' supply chain execution processes,
including fulfillment, warehousing, distribution and inventory management
|
|
Acquirer
|
Seller
|
Purchase Price*
|
Seller Revenue
|
Revenue Multiple
|
Description
|
|
BMC
Software
|
DGI
|
$3,000,000
|
$1,500,000 (estimate)
|
2.0x
|
Supplies
performance management tools for DB2 UDB on UNIX, Linux, and Windows
operating system platforms
|
|
BMC
Software
|
IT
Masters International S.A.
|
$42,000,000
|
$10,000,000 (estimate)
|
4.2x
|
Develops
service management technology
|
|
EMC
Corporation
|
Vmware
|
$635,000,000
|
$50,000,000
|
12.7x
|
Global
provider of virtual infrastructure software for Intel-based systems
|
|
Gores
Technology Group
|
Resonate
|
$54,000,000
|
$10,900,000
|
5.0x
|
Develops
application performance management and traffic management solutions for
business-critical environments
|
|
Micromuse
|
Network
Harmoni
|
$23,000,000
|
$4,000,000 (estimate)
|
5.8x
|
Develops
intelligent software agents that gathers data on the health and performance
of mission-critical business applications and systems
|
|
NaviSite
|
Interliant
|
$7,000,000
|
$44,600,000
|
0.2x
|
Infrastructure
solutions, encompassing messaging, security and hosting
|
|
Symantec
Corp.
|
ON
Technology Corp.
|
$95,360,000
|
$35,700,000
|
2.7x
|
Provider
of enterprise infrastructure management solutions
|
*Equity Value
Mergers
and Acquisitions: Select 2003 Software M&A Transactions
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
ACD Systems
(TSX: ASA)
|
Deneba
Systems
|
$5,500,000
|
$4,600,000
|
1.2x
|
Cash & Stock
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
ACD,
a developer of digital imaging and management software, acquires Deneba, a
provider of photo editing and desktop publishing applications. Deneba’s core
products and small file “foot print” complement ACD’s products and Web
distribution model. Deneba should also aid in diversifying ACD’s revenue,
likely derived mostly from its ACDSee product. ACD will pay $4.5 million in
cash and $1 million in stock, but seeking to preserve its cash balance, has
offered Deneba shareholders a 20% premium on any cash amount under $1.5
million taken in ACD stock.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Agilysys
(Nasdaq: AGYS)
|
Kyrus
|
$31,000,000
|
$130,000,000
|
0.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Amdocs
(NYSE: DOX)
|
Exchange
Applications (Pink Sheet: EXAP)
|
$5,000,000
|
$24,400,000
|
0.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Ascential
Software (Nasdaq:ASCL)
|
Mercator
Software
(Nasdaq:MCTR)
|
$97,900,000EV
|
$111,900,000
|
0.9x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
Fending
off a hostile bid from Strategic Software Holdings, enterprise
application/data integration provider Mercator agrees to a $106 million cash
offer from Ascential. Since spinning out from Informix, the acquisitive
Ascential has bought Vality, Torent Systems and Metagenix to beef up its data
warehousing suite. The deal represents a 22% premium to Mercator’s
shareholders. Ascential has more than $500 million in cash remaining.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Battery
Ventures
|
Made2Manage
Systems (Nasdaq:MTMS)
|
$13,516,000EV
|
$30,100,000
|
0.5x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
BMC Software
(NYSE: BMC)
|
IT Masters
Int’l
|
$42,000,000
|
$10,000,000
(estimate)
|
4.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
BMC,
the leader in IT systems management solutions, needed to extend its offering
to remain competitive with HP’s Open View and IBM’s Tivoli. By acquiring IT
Masters, BMC adds powerful adaptive service management solutions that enable
organizations to understand the real-time business impact of IT problems and
prioritize support efforts. Despite the economic downturn, IT Masters’
revenue grew 15% in Q2 and 30% in Q3 of 2002. We estimate IT Masters’ trailing twelve-month revenue to be $10
million.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
BMC Software
(NYSE: BMC)
|
Magic
Software unit of Network Associates
|
$47,000,000
|
$63,558,000
|
0.8x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Business
Objects (Nasdaq:BOJB)
|
Crystal
Decisions
|
$820,000,000
|
$270,000,000
|
3.0x
|
Cash / stock
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Cerberus
Capital Management / General Atlantic Partners
|
Baan
|
$135,000,000
|
$265,000,000
|
0.5x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Chinadotcom
(Nasdaq:CHINA)
|
Industri-Matematik
|
$25,000,000
|
$45,000,000
(estimate)
|
0.6x
|
ND
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
Five
days after its Ross buy, Chinadotcom (CDC) acquired 51% of IMI from Symphony
Technology Group, a financial investor that bought IMI in 4Q02 for $11
million, yielding a $14 million profit after just nine months. CDC needed a
supply chain solution company to round out its enterprise suite – which now
includes Ross. Look for CDC to cut costs by funneling IMI development to its
China R&D center. This rollup should enable CDC to lengthen its lead in
China and the Pac Rim. Symphony retains 49% of IMI.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Chinadotcom
(Nasdaq: CHINA)
|
Pivotal
Corp.
(Nasdaq: PVTL)
|
$56,239,200EV
|
$57,072,000
|
1.0x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Chinadotcom
(Nasdaq:
CHINA)
|
Ross Systems
(Nasdaq:
ROSS)
|
$66,110,000EV
|
$46,050,000
|
1.4x
|
Stock,
cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Cisco
Systems (NASDAQ: CSCO
|
Linksys
Group
|
$500,000,000
|
$429,000,000
|
1.2x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Cisco
Systems (NASDAQ: CSCO)
|
SignalWorks
|
$13,500,000
|
Unknown
|
n/a
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
EMC Corp.
(NYSE: EMC)
|
Documentum
(NASDAQ: DCTM)
|
$1,541,686,000EV
|
$274,724,000
|
5.6x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
EMC
(NYSE: EMC)
|
Legato
Systems (Nasdaq: LGTO)
|
$1,239,420,000EV
|
$280,300,000
|
4.4x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
EMC Corp.
(NYSE: EMC)
|
VMware
|
$635,000,000
|
$50,000,000
|
12.7x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Epicor
Software
(Nasdaq:
PIC)
|
ROI Systems
|
$20,700,000
|
$20,000,000
|
1.0x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
FileNet
(NASDAQ:
FILE)
|
Shana Corp.
|
$8,500,000
|
$7,500,000
(estimate)
|
1.1x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Group 1
Software (Nasdaq: GSOF)
|
Sagent
Technology (Nasdaq: SGNT)
|
$17,000,000
|
$37,900,000
|
0.5x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Hewitt
Associates (NYSE: HEW)
|
Cyborg Systems
|
$43,000,000
|
$40,000,000
|
1.1x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Hyperion
Solutions
(Nasdaq:
HYSL)
|
Brio
Software
(Nasdaq:
BRIO)
|
$116,500,000EV
|
$101,800,000
|
1.1x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Indus Int’l
(NASDAQ:
IINT)
|
SCT’s GEUS
Business
Unit
|
$39,000,000
|
$74,200,000
|
0.5x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Indus,
an enterprise asset management provider to the utility and energy markets,
picks up Systems and Computer Technology Corp’s Global Energy and Utility
Solutions (GEUS) business unit.
Here’s another example of a strategic acquisition in the same target
market offering immediate incremental revenue opportunities. Considering GEUS’s revenue, net assets of
$31.8 million and breakeven net income, it looks like Indus picked up GEUS
for a song. GEUS gives Indus a CIS
solution for its installed base, plus 200 new customers.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Interwoven
(Nasdaq:
IWVN)
|
iManage
(Nasdaq :IMAN)
|
$135,918,000EV
|
$42,700,000
|
3.2x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
EV:
Enterprise value = Purchase price, plus debt, minus cash &
equivalents
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Intuit
(Nasdaq:
INTU)
|
Income
Dynamics
|
$10,000,000
|
$3,500,000
(estimate)
|
2.9x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Intuit
(Nasdaq:
INTU)
|
Innovative
Merchant Solutions
|
$116,000,000
|
$25,000,000
|
4.6x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Itron
(Nasdaq:
ITRI)
|
Silicon
Energy
|
$71,200,000 EV
|
$15,000,000 (estimate)
|
4.8x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Itron,
a leading technology provider to major utilities worldwide moves into the
end-user market by announcing a bid for privately-held Silicon Energy, a
provider of enterprise energy management solutions. Silicon Energy filed,
then shelved an IPO back in 2001 at an implied market cap of $250 million.
The $71.2 million price tag is a 4.8x multiple over Silicon Energy’s trailing
revenue. Itron expects the deal to be mildly dilutive in 2003.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
JDA Software
(Nasdaq: JDAS)
|
Vista
Software Solutions
|
$4,300,000
|
$4,300,000
|
1.0x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Leading
retail industry software provider JDA beefs up its planning, forecasting and
supply chain solutions by acquiring the IP assets and staff of Vista
Software, a provider of data synchronization and integration solutions
linking retailers, distributors and manufacturers. This is an inexpensive
acquisition that will enable JDA customers to better manage trade promotions
and synchronize data throughout their supply and demand chains. Vista had
$1.4 million in software revenue.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Kofax
Imaging Products
|
Mohomine
|
$9,000,000
|
$1,500,000
(estimate)
|
6.0x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
L-3
Communications (NYSE: LLL)
|
Ship
Analytics
|
$11,400,000 EV
|
$25,000,000 (estimate)
|
0.5x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Beefing
up its homeland security offering, L-3 Communications picks up privately held
Ship Analytics (SA), a provider of crisis management software. Having partnered together earlier, L-3
decided to tie the knot and target state governments and FEMA. The purchase
price is largely contingent. L-3 will
pay $6.7 million, assume $4.7 million of Ship Analytics’ debt, and provide up
to an additional $20.2 million as an earnout, subject to financial
performance, through 2005. Ship
Analytics does not disclose its financials, but we estimate revenues in the
range of $25 million.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Macromedia
(Nasdaq: MACR)
|
eHelp Corp.
|
$65,000,000
|
$22,300,000 (estimate)
|
3.0x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
ManTech
Int’l Corp. (Nasdaq: MANT)
|
Integrated
Data Systems
|
$62,700,000EV
|
$40,000,000
|
1.6x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
ManTech,
an IT services provider to the Federal government, picks up software
developer and systems integrator IDS in order to beef up its secure messaging
and security network offering. IDS, with year-over-year growth exceeding 80%,
derives the vast majority of its revenue from ManTech’s target market - the
DoD and intelligence community.
ManTech paid 12.2 times IDS’ CY 2002 EBITDA and expects to receive
highly favorable tax treatment due to the structure of the deal. This is
ManTech’s third acquisition following its IPO in 2002.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
MASBC
Acquisition Corp.
|
Viador
(Nasdaq:
VIAD)
|
$1,080,000EV
|
$4,940,000
|
0.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
MICROS
Systems (Nasdaq: MCRS)
|
Datavantage
Corp.
|
$52,000,000
|
$42,000,000
|
1.2x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
MICROS,
a leader in IT services and solutions to the hospitality industry, acquires
Datavantage, a provider of POS software to the likes of Starbucks, IKEA and
Staples. MICROS rationalized the acquisition by pointing out hospitality
businesses often have retail operations. Fact is, MICROS is bucking the
current trend of staying “close to home” by moving into a new and different
vertical market that is faring better than travel and hospitality. Saratoga
Partners, Datavantage’s investors, earned a 43% IRR.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
NaviSite
(Nasdaq:
NAVI)
|
Interliant
(Nasdaq:
INIT)
|
$7,000,000
|
$44,600,000
|
0.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Navisite,
a provider of application management and hosting services, acquires
Interliant, a bankrupt competitor focused on corporate messaging and e-mail
outsourcing. It’s fourth acquisition of a hosting business in recent months,
NaviSite is taking advantage of depressed valuations and others’ misfortunes.
While the market reacted favorably to the acquisition, driving NaviSite’s
stock price upward 67%, we’re a little less enthusiastic. NaviSite has
significant debt, a dwindling cash balance and negative operating income.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Open Text
Corp. (Nasdaq: OTEX)
|
Corechange
|
$4,200,000
|
$18,000,000 (estimate)
|
0.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Open Text
Corp. (Nasdaq: OTEX)
|
Eloquent
Corp. (Nasdaq: ELOQ)
|
$6,720,000
|
$2,500,000
|
2.7x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Open Text
(Nasdaq: OTEX)
|
IXOS
Software (Nasdaq: XOSY)
|
$188,809,000EV
|
$145,000,000
|
1.3x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
Open
Text, a market leader in collaboration and knowledge management software,
buys German content management and archiving tools provider IXOS Software.
Though positioned as complementary, Open Text eliminates a competitor in a
deal that denotes continued consolidation in the content management arena.
Open Text gains greater access to the SAP base and 2,700 new customers. But
contrast the multiple here, typical for a consolidation play, with the
multiple paid by strategic buyer EMC for Open Text rival Documentum. Open
Text, which also recently purchased Germany’s Gauss Interprises, remains fair
game for acquisition itself. Like collaboration software, document management
is rapidly being subsumed into broader enterprise categories.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Opsware
(Nasdaq: OPSW)
|
Tangram
Enterprise Solutions (TESI.OB)
|
$10,000,000EV
|
$10,435,000
|
1.0 x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Oracle Corp.
(Nasdaq:
ORCL)
|
PeopleSoft
(Nasdaq:
PSFT)
|
$4,170,000,000EV
|
$1,930,000,000
|
2.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
On
the heels of the PeopleSoft/J.D. Edwards announcement, Oracle responded
promptly by tendering a hostile bid for PeopleSoft in the amount of
$5.1billion, or $16 per share. Viewed by many as a grossly inadequate offer,
PeopleSoft’s stock price was bid up from $15 to $18 in anticipation of a
higher offer by Oracle or a white knight.
Less than two weeks later, Oracle revised its bid upward 22% to $19.50
per share, but many obstacles remain.
Oracle, which has historically abstained from acquisitions, was
sufficiently threatened by the prospect of a PeopleSoft/Edwards merger to act
as spoiler offering most of its $6 billion of cash. As of January 2004,
Oracle continues its pursuit, most recently offering $26 per share.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
PeopleSoft
(Nasdaq:
PSFT)
|
J.D. Edwards
(Nasdaq:
JDEC)
|
$1,350,000,000EV
|
$886,000,000
|
1.5x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Perot
Systems
(NYSE: PER)
|
Soza &
Company
|
$75,000,000
|
$137,000,000
|
0.6x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
In
the IT services arena, Perot Systems acquires Soza & Co. a professional
services firm strongly focused on defense and homeland security, growth
sectors which are clear priorities for Perot. Soza expands Perot’s Government Services Group, adding 900
employees and $137 million in revenue to the Perot Group’s 600 employees and
$63 million of revenue. With an
earnout in cash and stock of $32 million, the purchase price can approach a
0.8x revenue multiple, not bad for a services provider.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Plato
Learning (Nasdaq: TUTR)
|
Lightspan
(Nasdaq:
LSPND)
|
$32,970,000EV
|
$50,000,000
|
0.7x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
After
racking up substantial losses, ($33.5 million on $50 million revenue in
fiscal year ’03) and with only enough cash to fund two more quarters,
education software vendor Lightspan sells to Plato Learning, a financially
challenged provider of e-courseware to community colleges. Plato, which lost
$5.7 million of operating income on $78 million in revenue during the last
twelve months, hopes to beef up its presence in Lightspan’s K-12 market.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Primavera
Systems
|
Evolve
Software
(Nasdaq:
EVLV)
|
$13,000,000
|
$18,300,000
|
0.7x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Progress Software
Corp. (Nasdaq: PRGS)
|
DataDirect
Technologies Ltd.
|
$88,000,000
|
$35,500,000 (estimate)
|
2.5x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
Progress
Software acquires privately held Data Direct Technologies, the leading
developer of data access and connectivity components for software developers,
in a $88 million, all-cash deal.
Data Direct’s products are embedded in the apps of more than 250 software
companies and most of the Fortune 100. Progress, which grew 13% in its fiscal
year-ending 11/30/03, has now moved well beyond its 4th GL
development platform days and is considered a major software infrastructure
player. Plans are for DataDirect to operate as a separate business unit to
maintain an appearance of impartiality, similar to another highly successful
Progress subsidiary, Sonic Software, its fully owned Internet middleware
company. The transaction should be cash-flow-positive and slightly dilutive
in year one and accretive thereafter.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Pumatech
(Nasdaq: PUMA)
|
Synchrologic
|
$60,000,000
|
$11,800,000
|
5.1x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
Synchronization
and mobile app solution provider Pumatech, with $25 million revenue and $27 million
left in cash, pays a whopping $60 million
(all stock) for competitor Synchrologic ($11.8 million rev). The two firms had been locked in patent litigation
brought by Pumatech. For Pumatech, the deal eliminates that headache, as well
as a competitor, and provides access to better synchronization and device
management technology. Pumatech previously acquired Starfish, Loudfire and
Spontaneous Technology.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Red Hat Inc.
(Nasdaq:
RHAT)
|
Sistina
Software
|
$31,000,000
|
$2,250,000 (estimate)
|
13.8x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
Open
Source Linux powerhouse Red Hat will acquire storage infrastructure software
maker Sistina Software in an all-stock deal valued at $31 million. As evidenced by the 13.8x multiple, this is a highly
strategic buy for Red Hat as it battles to replace proprietary systems in
large corporation with open source Linux applications. Red Hat will retain
Sistina's development team and plans to bring an open source version of
Sistina's software out by mid-year. With this acquisition, Red Hat expands
its applications offering beyond Web portals and content management. An
application server is slated to join Red Hat’s line-up later this year.
Sistina’s revenue is a D&B estimate.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Saratoga
Partners
(NASDAQ:
FILE)
|
Divine’s
Managed Services Unit
|
$28,000,000
|
$60,000,000
|
0.5x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
ScanSoft
(Nasdaq:SSFT)
|
SpeechWorks
Int’l (Nasdaq: SPWX)
|
$133,756,000EV
|
$36,000,000
|
3.7x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
ScanSoft, a leading developer of digital imaging
software, continues to redefine itself by picking up publicly traded
SpeechWorks, a speech recognition and text-to-speech vendor. This is
ScanSoft’s third acquisition in this sector. ScanSoft clearly considers
SpeechWorks to be highly strategic, considering the 63% premium it paid for a
company that has historically lost significant amounts of cash. ScanSoft
expects the deal to be 5% accretive after eliminating $27 million through headcount cuts and office
consolidations.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Secure
Computing
(Nasdaq:
SCUR)
|
N2H2
(NTWO.OB)
|
$15,813,000EV
|
$11,100,000
|
1.4x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
SCO Group
(Nasdaq: SCOX)
|
Vultus
|
$2,700,000
|
$1,250,000
(estimate)
|
2.2x
|
Stock
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
SERENA
Software (Nasdaq: SRNA)
|
TeamShare
|
$18,000,000
|
$12,500,000
(estimate)
|
1.4x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Serena,
a provider of software solutions used to manage enterprise application code
and Web content changes, picks-up TeamShare, a “SoftLetter 100” provider of
developer-oriented collaboration and workflow management tools. TeamShare’s
product, which is already integrated with Serena’s, provides a highly
complementary product extension for Serena. Revenue is estimated to be $12.5
million.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
SSA Global
Technologies
|
Elevon
(Nasdaq:
ELVN)
|
$20,280,000
|
$33,000,000
|
0.6x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
SSA GT, an enterprise software provider whose strategy
is growth through acquisition, acquires Elevon, a global provider of
collaborative commerce solutions. Elevon reported LTM revenue of $33 million, but backing out revenue from its recently
divested UK operation, actual revenue was about $21 million, and the future
looked bleak. Revenue fell 33% in the first quarter to $4 million and the
company had a net loss of $1.5 million. Although the offer represents a 20%
premium over Elevon’s current market cap, it’s actually less than Elevon’s
$21 million cash on its balance sheet.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
SSA Global
Technologies
|
EXE
Technologies
(Nasdaq:EXEE)
|
$16,026,000EV
|
$73,656,000
|
0.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Stellent
(Nasdaq:
STEL)
|
Ancept
|
$2,770,000
|
$4,500,000
(estimate)
|
0.6x
|
Stock, cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
The
content management sector consolidated further as Stellent picked up small,
privately-held digital asset management vendor Ancept, an IBM partner. After
Stellent competitors Documentum and Interwoven recently acquired digital
asset management developers (Bulldog and MediaBin), Stellent had little
choice but to embed the technology in its offering. Ancept shareholders
receive $2 million in cash and 100,000 shares of Stellent stock.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
SunGard Data
Systems (NYSE: SDS)
|
Caminus
Corp. (Nasdaq: CAMZ)
|
$119,000,000EV
|
$84,000,000
|
1.4x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Sungard,
the leader in financial services software, moves aggressively into the energy
vertical, acquiring Caminus, a developer of trading and risk-management
systems for that sector. Sungard’s
value has declined 9.1% since its $9 a share offer, a $6.50 premium over Caminus’ trading price. We
disagree. Backing out Caminus’ estimated $40 million cash balance, Sungard paid only 1.4x trailing 12 month
revenue for a company growing at almost 50% annually. Caminus’ net losses are largely due to
amortization expenses relating to prior acquisitions.
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
SunGard Data
Systems (NYSE: SDS)
|
HTE
(Nasdaq:
HTEI)
|
$96,900,000EV
|
$70,000,000
|
1.4x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
SunGard
continues to ramp up its public services operating unit with the acquisition
of HTE, a leader in IT and software solutions to the government sector,
especially local agencies. Backing
out HTE’s cash balance of $24.1 million,
SunGard pays a 1.4x multiple, or $96.9 million. Although HTE’s revenue has hovered for the
past two years around $65 million,
it returned to profitability in 2002, attracting SunGard’s interest.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Sungard Data
Systems (NYSE: SDS)
|
Systems
& Computer Technology Corp.
|
$491,200,000
|
$269,700,000
|
1.8x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Symantec
Corp. (Nasdaq:SYMC)
|
Nexland
(OTC:XLND)
|
$20,100,000EV
|
$7,740,000
|
2.6x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s Insight:
Symantec
continues to reposition as a security software provider by acquiring Nexland,
a small public company whose patent-pending security applications and
appliances enable secure virtual private networking between corporate and
remote offices. Here’s another example of a strategic partnership evolving
into an acquisition with a decent multiple. After backing out Nexland’s cash
and adding debt, Symantec paid $20.1 million.
Nexland’s compound annual revenue growth rate exceeded 129% over the last two
years.
|
|
Buyer
|
Seller
|
Price
|
Revenue
|
Multiple
|
Currency
|
|
Symantec
(Nasdaq: SYMC)
|
ON
Technology (Nasdaq: ONTC)
|
$81,660,000EV
|
$37,500,000
|
2.2x
|
Cash
|
|
SEG’s
Insight:
Symantec
further expands its administration software line with the acquisition of ON
Technology, a leading provider of software distribution and configuration
management solutions. Symantec, which had focused primarily on enterprise
security software, has been building out storage management and IT
administration product lines through a series of strategic buys, including
September’s purchase of PowerQuest. Through acquisitions, the company has
successfully redefined itself as an enterprise infrastructure solution
provider.
|
Our predictions for 2004? Should the
economy continue to improve, IT spending increase to projected levels, and
technology sector stock prices hold, we estimate the total number of North
American software industry M&A transactions will increase 25% to 1,650
transactions. We believe strategic technology buys will comprise about 60% of
these deals and new category buys about 25%. Consolidations, roll-ups,
financial buyouts will account for most of the balance. We see median
valuations improving further, in a range of 2.3x – 2.5x TTM revenue.
This
report was prepared by Software Equity Group, L.L.C. (SEG), a mergers and
acquisitions advisory firm serving the software, life science and technology
sectors. SEG is solely responsible for its content. This material is based on
data obtained from sources we deem to be reliable; it is not guaranteed as to
its accuracy and does not purport to be complete. This information is not to be
used as the primary basis of investment decisions. For more, please visit www.softwareequity.com, or phone
(858) 509-2800.
|